Showing posts with label freedom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label freedom. Show all posts

Tuesday, 20 January 2015

Has democracy had its day?


DEMOCRACY is in crisis. We must save democracy. 
It is a familiar chant of Western politicians. The reality is that while it may make a good soundbite to motivate a flagging electorate shouting about how much trouble democracy is in serves no purpose.
Part of the problem is that no-one actually seems to know what democracy is any more. I am not talking about a historical definition here but a subjective philosophical one.
Is democracy that which Western states decree? An excuse for war? A path to extremism and xenophobia? Is it even the removal of freedoms from some in the name of the "greater good".
Democracy has become a hot topic once more this week as Britain marks 750 years since its first parliament was elected.
This year also marks another key anniversary in the history of democracy, 800 years since the signing of the Magna Carta. Even this most notable document in the evolution of Western democracy does not reflect the governance we currently have today.
Democracy is at its ideological core about allowing all people to have a voice, however, as declining voter turnout has demonstrated, less and less people are actually taking the opportunity to have their voices heard.
Ostensibly interventions in Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya were, at least tentatively on paper, part carried out to bring democracy. What democracy though? 
Western imposed democracy forcing different cultural and sociological ideals on countries provided that they elect governments who will be more malleable to American and British interests in the region.
The elections may have had the look of being free and fair but how much does this really matter if everyone knows that the winner must support the West or face removal and the whole process being repeated. It is a global power politics version of a teacher keeping the class behind until everyone gets it right.
In the West several commentators have warned that the latest crisis to face democracy is the rise of the populist movement. I have no love for Britain's United Kingdom Independence Party, America's Tea Party movement et al. They play on fear and disillusionment. They use blame games and the politics of hate to entice the dispossessed. 
In a democracy though we must face that parties such as this may gain power. It is not that democracy is in crisis, this is democracy in action.
If more mainstream parties want to put the threat to democracy to rest then they must debate effectively and challenge the principles of hate which are fuelling these parties.
There is a wider question though. Has democracy had its day? Is it time for a new political system. Eight hundred years since the Magna Carta. It is nothing more than a flash in the pan of political institutions. While it's very principle may have started with the Greeks its implementation has proven a long and arduous journey.
Not everything lasts. Religion, politics and art fade away over time. As we increase surveillance on our citizens, denigrate our opponents, dismiss ideas and hide from principles of unity. As we sacrifice morals and ethics on the great altar of Western democracy and bury culture and systems which have survived for millennia because they don't fit anymore, is it not time to consider that the future of freedom may be what is truly in crisis. A crisis caused in no small measure by our blind approach to democracy.

Monday, 23 June 2014

Hard fought freedom proven a farce

SENIOR British Politicians have condemned Egyptian authorities over today's sentencing of three Al Jazeera journalists.
Prime Minister David Cameron said that he "was completely appalled" by the seven year sentences for two of the men, with a third given ten years, for effectively reporting in the situation within Egypt.
Foreign Secretary William Hague has reportedly summoned the Egyptian Ambassador to discuss the disturbing development in the country's slide back to an authoritarian state.
The three men, who continue to protest their innocence, include Australian Peter Greste, Al Jazeera's Kenya-based correspondent, Baher Mohamed and Canadian-Egyptian national Mohamed Fahmy, Cairo bureau chief of Al Jazeera English. They were accused of aiding the former political party the Muslim Brotherhood, which has been categorised as a terrorist organisation by Egypt's current leadership, and reporting false news.
A further six Journalists, two of whom are British, were convicted in abstentia. Mr Hague has called upon the Egyptian authorities, along with President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, to review the sentences. 
Attempting to cover the news of their imprisoned colleagues journalists from Al Jazeera were forced to rely on information from other broadcasters after being banned from operating in the country.
In a statement following the ruling, Al Jazeera English's managing director Al Anstey said the sentence "defies logic, sense, and any semblance of justice".
“Today three colleagues and friends were sentenced, and will continue behind bars for doing a brilliant job of being great journalists.  “Guilty” of covering stories with great skill and integrity.  ”Guilty” of defending people’s right to know what is going on in their world.   
“Peter, Mohamed, and Baher and six of our other colleagues were sentenced despite the fact that not a shred of evidence was found to support the extraordinary and false charges against them.
"There is only one sensible outcome now.  For the verdict to be overturned, and justice to be recognised by Egypt.  We must keep our voice loud to call for an end to their detention.  Alongside us is a worldwide solidarity, a global call for their release, and a demand for basic freedoms to be respected."
Human rights group Amnesty International have classified the three imprisoned journalists as "prisoners of conscience" and condemned the ruling, based on trumped up charges and no evidence, as an attempt to silence what is left of freedom of speech in Egypt.
 "This is a devastating verdict for the men and their families, and a dark day for media freedom in Egypt, when journalists are being locked up and branded criminals or ‘terrorists’ simply for doing their job,” said Philip Luther, Director of the Middle East and North Africa at Amnesty International. 
“The only reason these three men are in jail is because the Egyptian authorities don’t like what they have to say. They are prisoners of conscience and must be immediately and unconditionally released. In Egypt today anyone who dares to challenge the state’s narrative is considered a legitimate target.”
A shadow hangs heavily over the hopes which so many had following the Arab Spring and the overthrow of Hosni Mubarak. While Mr Hague appeals to the Egyptian government to respect press freedoms there will be many who see this as a direct assault on liberty. Today's guilty verdicts will be seen as further evidence of President Sisi's hardline attitude to anything which may threaten his authoritarian power, and lead to renewed calls for genuine freedom and democracy in the country.

Thursday, 12 June 2014

Press freedom prevails over secret trials

SECRET trials have been ruled out by the British court of appeals following action by media groups.
Prosecutors had originally pushed for the trial of Erol Incedal and Mounir Rarmoul-Bouhadjar to be closed to the media and public, claiming it was a matter of national security. 
According to reports by the British Broadcasting Corporation Mr Incedal is charged with preparing for acts of terrorism, contrary to the Terrorism Act 2006 and a further allegation of collecting information useful to terrorism. Mr Rarmoul-Bouhadjar has been accused of possession of false identities and collecting information useful to terrorism.
In a statement following the verdict judges from the Court of Appeal said: "Open justice is both a fundamental principle of the common law and a means of ensuring public confidence in our legal system; exceptions are rare and must be justified on the facts.
"Any such exceptions must be necessary and proportionate. No more than the minimum departure from open justice will be countenanced."
The prosecution has previously stated that if reporting was allowed on the trail then it may be forced to abandon the case.
Ahead of the hearing Anthony Hudson, representing the media groups, was reported as saying: 
"We submit that the orders made mark such a significant departure from the principle of open justice that they are inconsistent with the rule of law and democratic accountability," adding. "This case is a test of the court's commitment to that constitutional principle in the admittedly difficult and sensitive cases where the state seeks to have trials involving terrorism heard in secret and relies in support of that on grounds of national security."
Despite striking down arguments that the entire trial should be held in secret strict rules have been laid down for what can and cannot be reported.
According the ruling journalists will be allowed to cover the swearing in of the jury and reading the charges, part of the judge's introductory remarks and a portion of the prosecution opening speech. If the defendants are found guilty then coverage of the verdicts and sentencing will be permitted.
The news has been welcomed by the press and human rights groups which had condemned the original decision as against the principles of British justice.
Former Prime Minister Tony Blair's, wife Cherie Blair, an internationally renowned human rights lawyer, has given her view on the subject during an interview with a legal publication. 
"Secret courts can occasionally be justified. It is all about proportionality and where you draw the line. And who draws the line," explained Mrs Blair.
Previous attempts to hold secret trials in the UK have brought widespread condemnation from charities and the public. During one attempt in 2012 Amnesty International released a strongly worded statement criticising the government's plans.
"These proposals are dangerous and should be dropped," said Tara Lyle, Policy Adviser at Amnesty International UK.
“They will allow the government to throw a cloak of secrecy over wrongdoing, including matters as serious as the alleged involvement by UK officials in rendition, secret detention, enforced disappearances and torture."